If you isolate down to just the tech sector, patent trolls were responsible for 90 percent of all patent lawsuits in the first half of 2015. Patent trolls have branched out from suing large businesses to suing everyone from retailers to grocers to. Nonpracticing entities npes are legal entities that own patents but do not pursue any form of development. It acquired ip from distressed companies and filed more than a dozen patent lawsuits. Ask a software developertheyre likely to know someone who has been sued or. Thats because trolls are filing an unprecedented number of expensive lawsuits. A copy of this bill can be found via the library of congress. Supreme court ruling bolsters zohos stand against patent trolls. The legal battle has been protracted, and it involves multiple lawsuits and a dizzying number of appeals. From an open source perspective, any reform that reduces the risk and expense of patent lawsuits is surely a good thing.
The gnome foundation has filed a defence against the patent lawsuit it received a month ago, saying it wants to send a message to all software patent trolls out there. As we have explained previously, patent trolls benefit from a. Update on the current landscape of patent troll lawsuits. As we previously reported, there are serious concerns with the studies asserting that a patent litigation explosion has been caused by patent licensing companies socalled nonpracticing entities npes or patent trolls. If anyone tells you that they can deter troll litigationrun the. Patent trolls often sue with weak software patents, so when they are actually challenged in court, they usually lose.
Its no surprise that patent trolls would target open source, such as sound views lawsuit against fidelity directed at multiple oss components, including jquery, openstack object storage swift, apache hbase, and apache storm. If a patent troll can make the litigation so painful for a tech company that it would rather pay to get rid of the suit, then the troll has won. Gao report confirms no patent troll litigation problem. Rackspace targets patent troll to stop the lawsuits. Gnome sends message to patent trolls and files defence. Companies which do not rely on massive software patent portfolios in the software patent wars do not see any difference in the threat of patent rolls and the threat of competing companies that make a product. After we were sued by blackbird, we decided that we wouldnt roll over. Patent trolling and technology patent troll lawsuits. The 4,057 patent lawsuits filed in united states federal district courts throughout 2017 was the lowest total for an entire year since 2011. Momentum seems to be building in congress to tackle patent reform.
Google donates patents to protect cloud software from lawsuits. This american life dedicated two hourlong episodes to. Maybe they did score an overly broad patent themselves on their own software, maybe they. With patent trolls bankruptcy filings, advocates departures and a decline in the number of granted us patents were seeing a sort of recession if not depression in the patent microcosm. The huge societal costs of npe software patent lawsuits. A patent troll or patent assertion entity is a company with no business except licensing patents and suing for patent infringement. Rackspace targets patent troll to stop the lawsuits zdnet. Patent gold rush to blame for patent sharks, patent trolls. The supreme courts big ruling on patent trolls will. The government and the courts are finally getting fed up. Patent trolls found a few federal court districts where they had greater odds of winning. More than a year after the senate defeated a bill aimed at curbing patent troll lawsuits, another bill recently emerged in the house referred to as the innovation act. But the reforms under current discussion so far have largely been focused on the problem of npes nonpracticing entities and have not directly addressed the problem of software patents. A patent troll acquires patents to make profits by bringing patent infringement lawsuits.
Open source software is also in the crosshairs of numerous cloud patent lawsuits. Patent trolls have no products to attack with patents so large software patent portfolios are worthless in defending against a patent troll. Here we go again software patents poised to make a comeback under new patent office rules new rule narrows landmark 2014 supreme court decision limiting software patents. Patent trolls target small businesses with lawsuit threats.
How hightech banks are fighting back against patent trolls. To fight or to settle, that is the question patent troll, or nonpracticing entity npe, is a derogatory term used to label people or companies that exploit patents as a business strategy. Many patent trolls specifically target startup companies. Cloud computing patent litigation trends competitor. These seemingly alarming studies see here and here have drawn scholarly criticism for their use of proprietary, secret data collected from companies like. Another researcher calculated that 60 percent of the patent troll revenue came from patents related to software and high tech, with the especially aggressive cases focused on pure software. They often buy up patents cheaply from companies down on their luck who are. The quantity of such lawsuits began to grow rapidly last decade. Patentrelated litigation made up more than half of all lawsuits filed in america last year, a forty percent increase from three years before. When broken down into different categories, patent trolls and software patents lose their lawsuits most often. Patent trolls, also known as nonpracticing entities, are companies that prosecute, buy, or license patents, and once the patents are issued or acquired.
Of course, if the troll has picked a friendly court. Patent troll lawsuits up 11% versus last year pcmag. Google and a group of top android phone makers have sealed a new agreement to collectively defend themselves against patent lawsuits. Over 5,000 firms were named as defendants in patent troll. Patent troll that sued over apple watch and 80 other.
First, the explosion in patent troll litigation is somewhat of an illusion. In international law and business, patent trolling or patent hoarding is a categorical or. They are one of the main causes for patent wars, representing more than one third of software patent cases. As many as 55% of all patent defendants and 82% of pae patent troll defendants have been sued on the basis of a software patent share of patent litigation defendants sued on the basis of a software patent. Instead, trolls are in the business of litigation or even just threatening litigation. Under the name of versata software, trilogy morphed into a patent troll. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis the. With socalled patent troll lawsuits on the rise in a big way, i thought itd be a good time to highlight the interesting, funny, and littleknown side of american patent, trademark, and law. An ftc report and blistering court opinion could spell the end to software patents and patent trolls. Within the software industry, patent trolls are the lowest of the low, exploiting americas complex patent.
Ask a software developer theyre likely to know someone who has been sued or. Theres a derogatory term in silicon valley for companies that amass huge troves of patents and make money by threatening lawsuits. Patent troll akoloutheo sues oracle in latest chapter of. Most software patent trolls lose lawsuits slashdot. Patent trolls may have bled companies for half a trillion dollars in the past two decades, a new study finds. Personally, i believe the vast majority of software patents are obvious and trivial. The data suggests that most companies, when threatened with a lawsuit, end up settling or licensing to avoid the high costs of litigating. Supreme court ruling could hinder patent trolls the. Patent trolls are known to shop for favorable litigation venues. On wednesdaythursday, for example, unified patents showed that patent litigation is dominated by patent trolls, at least when it comes to software patents dressed up as internet of things. Fueling the trend are socalled patent trolls known for making their money by suing. In many cases, companies develop new technologies thinking. When jeff kellings internet company fototime was sued along with more than other companies for violating someones patent, he wondered if it was a troll which the company denies, and.
But in may 2017, the supreme court issued a ruling that companies. While some may suggest this means the system is working, thats not really true. Parable of a patent troll and its prodigal software patent. The problem is that normal patent litigation is extremely expensive and companies with real businesses are well aware of this and are careful about initiating. One of the greatest dangers to innovators is the risk of frivolous lawsuits from patent trolls. Patent trolls have recently shifted from targeting huge tech firms to bullying startups, which lack the resources to fight back. Patent trolls are in the business of patent litigation, enforcing their. Using overbroad patents based on dated technology, trolls threaten litigation and bring infringement suits against inventors. Lawsuits brought by patent assertion companies made up 61% of all patent cases in 2012, according to the santa clara university school of law.
Trolls, also known as nonpracticing entities, typically do not produce products or services, but are in the business of litigation. Heres how one startup fought back when fitnessring maker motiv got a threat from mhm, it went public with the response. When broken down into different categories, patent trolls and software patents lose their lawsuits. According to the ftc, approximately 2700 patent lawsuits are filed each year.
From 19952011, patent trolls won fewer than 25% of cases that went to judgment. Washington the supreme court on monday placed tight limits on where patent lawsuits may be filed a unanimous decision that was a blow to. An anonymous reader writes a new study is out concerning patent trolls and software patents, which found the rather surprising news that the most litigated patents tend to lose nearly 90% of the time. One problem is that the pledge will have little effect against patent trolls like intellectual ventures, which buy up old patents and use them to file lawsuits against productive companies. Software patents, trolls, and the fight for innovation. Intellectual property disputes threaten to spread to new venue. Developers voiced concern that this clause allowed facebook to initiate patent lawsuits while restricting defensive lawsuits against them. The president, in a series of executive actions, asked the patent office to take steps to block frivolous lawsuits filed by socalled patent trolls. Patent trolls, by design, are entirely immune from the threats posed by any outstanding patents. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis. Many in the open source community were wary of the legalsavvy tech giant using a hatchet to deal with fears of. The case against software patents, in 9 charts vox. Wwe sued over wwe network technology by notorious patent trolls.
Cloud provider rackspace is suing what it sees as one of the biggest patent trolls in the united states in. Even though its easter so weve been writing less the uspto continues granting patents and lawsuits continue to be filed. The economic burden of todays patent lawsuits is, in fact, historically unprecedented. The unclear boundaries of software patents make them well suited for patent trolls. Patent trolling isnt dead its just moving to delaware. The report states that many recent patent infringement lawsuits are related to the. So why are there so many lawsuits over software patents.
The demise of patent trolls and software patents in the us. Googles head of patents and patent strategy said in march 2009. Rather, the patent claims the use of computer and software components to perform routine database and communications operations. Supreme court ruling bolsters zohos stand against patent. Wwe sued over wwe network technology by notorious patent. Obama issues orders to stop patent trolls the new york. Google and top android partners agree to share software. The patent troll crisis is really a software patent crisis thats because trolls are filing an unprecedented number of expensive lawsuits.
In 2014, price waterhouse coopers published research into patent litigation including a. Patent troll that sued over apple watch and 80 other fitness products meets its match ceo defends patent lawsuits. They lie in wait for someone to create a process or product that has some relationship to the. Software patents worth billions come before high court.
1362 143 347 931 776 839 588 1101 1585 1498 306 553 91 336 1180 990 1096 1119 1432 31 227 297 380 1467 110 916 730 1133 724 886 616 35